The following criteria were adopted by the committee in October 1975 for selection of an Underwood Award recipient.
-- The award recipient must be currently employed at Florissant Valley.
-- The award recipient must have a strong record of the achievement of excellence in instruction or instruction-related activities.
-- The award recipient must have a record of evidence that shows a genuine contribution to the field of education, and a humanistic concern for faculty, students and all persons in education.
--The award recipient must have made contributions clearly beyond what would normally be expected, and these contributions must be demonstrated over an extended period of time.
-- The award recipient must have satisfied these criteria during his or her tenure at Florissant Valley.
The recipient is selected on the basis of a consensus of the committee members (who are the three most recent Underwood Award winners).